|
To those that make server based email filters and those ISP that
use them: First problem - I am getting tired
of dealing with messages from filters that send out email that does
nothing but say the message has been blocked. Don't get me wrong, It
is a good thing that any spam email that is spoofing my email
address or domain gets killed before it reaches a live user (I don't
have to deal with the hate mail from users that think I sent it),
however sending notice of it is totally pointless. Spammers and bots
are not going to care, the victim of the address spoof won't be able
to do anything with it (only make them worry about it), and it just
adds to the network congestion.
second problem - It is not good if my legitimate
email get blocked, because a filter blindly added my email address
or domain to a black list. Black lists based on email address/domain don't work, spammers never
use there own networks, domains or addresses anymore.
A problem designed by a clever spammer needs a
clever yet simple solution!
I have an idea, why not filters that when it
receives an email suspected of being spam it holds it and sends a
link (and message ID) to the sender/reply address to visit the
filter's web page for sender verification. If the sent verification
email bounces back as unknown user or invalid address, it knows the
received email is bogus and kills it. If sends successfully, however
no visit in 10 days, it kills it. If the sender does visit the page,
he/she has to type in a code that is on screen that is only human
readable. If successful the email message is delivered. If the sent
verification message is received by a sever that is also running the
same or compatible filter, it checks it's send log (for matching
message ID), if so lets the verification message in for the sender
to verify, if not, bounces the verification message allowing the
first filter to dump the spam message.
This would work, spammers are not going to
manually verify thousands (not even hundreds) of sent emails. If
all email servers had this system, spam could be history.
If you have comments or suggestions on this please
let me know.
Wayne D Schulz,
NetWarden.net / WebTerritory.net |